Thanks a ton for the responses guys, I really appreciate it.
So I ran my route today and had the intention of talking/pulling the box (it's a mint honor box), and I was surprised to see the correct amount of money in it. 0% theft. Found out there's a new manager, and she asked if I had any other candy (I told her I also run triple heads filled with candy) and she let me put one of those in today.
Wild day. Expected to lose an account, but ended up upgrading the account. Never know how this business is going to go, lol.